Standardized testing is back – And “test-optional” isn’t what it used to be

While many families assume that the test-optional era made the SAT and ACT a thing of the past, a major reversal has quietly reshaped the admissions landscape—and ignoring test scores could put your student at a significant disadvantage.
Consider a student we worked with, whom we’ll call Marcus. He was an ideal applicant by every classroom measure: a 3.9 GPA, varsity cross-country captain, and a stack of AP courses. Because so many colleges had adopted test-optional policies over the past several years, Marcus and his parents decided not to invest much time in prep. He took the SAT once without studying, got an average score, and decided not to submit it.
He felt confident hitting “submit” on his applications to a mix of selective private universities and flagship state schools. After all, test-optional meant his grades and activities would speak for themselves.
Or so they thought.
When decisions rolled out, Marcus was waitlisted or denied at almost every reach and target school on his list. His parents were stunned—until they looked closer at how colleges are actually evaluating applicants today.
Testing is back
Welcome to the standardized testing pendulum swing. All eight Ivy League universities have reinstated—or announced the return of—testing requirements, alongside selective schools like MIT, Stanford, Caltech, Johns Hopkins, Georgetown, and Notre Dame. Even more surprising for families is the shift among major public flagships. Schools like the University of Texas at Austin, Ohio State, Penn State, Purdue, the University of Florida, Georgia Tech, the University of Georgia, and the University of Tennessee now require test scores.
And what about the schools that remain officially “test-optional”? According to admissions data released by several selective institutions, applicants who submit strong scores are often admitted at noticeably higher rates than non-submitters. In short, at most elite and increasingly more state flagship schools, testing is treated as required, not optional.
Strategy over rankings
The goal of any college search should be “right fit,” not “highest ranked.” We only highlight these selective private and flagship universities to illustrate a critical reality: in a world of holistic admissions, strong test scores remain a meaningful differentiator—especially for students on the bubble.
That is not to suggest that a stellar SAT or ACT score will rescue a weak GPA, or that every college on your student’s list requires testing. Many wonderful colleges remain genuinely test-optional or test-blind. However, skipping testing altogether limits your student’s options before the search even begins—and can even cost your family thousands of dollars in automatic merit scholarships that are still tied to test scores.
What you can do
Start with a baseline test sophomore year. Don’t wait until junior spring to see where your student stands. Have them take a full-length practice SAT and ACT to determine which format suits their strengths better, giving them plenty of time to prep without added stress.
Check the fine print on every school’s policy. Policies are shifting rapidly—some schools have reinstated requirements for the current cycle, while others have mandates kicking in for the next entering class. Verify the exact rule on each college’s admissions website so you aren’t caught by surprise.
This topic is a fast moving target with real implications for getting accepted (or not) and unlocking merit aid (or not). Schedule a hour’s worth of free advice with our team and let us help you navigate this new college admissions environment.
